America’s Most Charming Christmas Towns of 2025, According to Poll
When we asked more than 3,000 Americans which real-life towns most deserve to be the setting of a Hallmark Christmas movie, the results offered more than just a feel-good list – they doubled as a snapshot of the places people most enjoy escaping to during the holidays.
From small-town main streets to snowy mountain hideaways, the choices reveal the kinds of domestic destinations that travelers gravitate toward when they are looking for comfort, charm, and a little seasonal magic.
Once you line the towns up, clear patterns start to emerge in what Americans consider the perfect festive backdrop.
<iframe src=”https://exoticca-2.
Key Findings
Mountain Magic
One of the first things you notice while looking at the list is how many of these towns sit in the mountains.
Not just the obvious ones like Estes Park or Lake Placid – even places you don’t immediately think of as “alpine” (Blue Ridge, Whitefish, Jackson, Blowing Rock) have that mix of fresh air, pine trees, and old lodges.
It’s the kind of scenery that almost writes the script for you: snow, fireplaces, hot chocolate, repeat. People clearly lean toward places where winter actually feels like winter.
Coastal Glow
But then you get a handful of coastal picks that throw the pattern off in a good way. Bar Harbor, Rockport, Ocean Springs, and even St. Augustine – all very different, yet they carry the same sort of quiet, twinkly charm once December hits.
There is something about Christmas lights reflecting on water that seems to do the same emotional job as a snowfall.
Victorian Charm
Galena, Cape May, Eureka Springs, Brownville. None of these is considered a hugely popular destination in the traditional tourism sense, but they all have that careful, almost storybook look that makes you slow down. Wooden porches, bay windows, and wreaths on every door.
Midwestern Cozy
The Midwest is well represented. Not flashy places, not big landmarks — just towns that feel lived-in and warm.
Cedar Rapids, Geneva-on-the-Lake, Bayfield… all solid choices from people who prefer coziness over drama. You can almost picture locals stringing lights across the main street themselves.
Sunshine Christmas
Towns in warm-weather states were popular too. St. Augustine, Ocean Springs, Sedona, Carmel-by-the-Sea – all proof that sunshine doesn’t ruin the holiday mood.
Some people clearly picture Christmas as more of a soft-sweater affair than a snow-boot one. A little sand or red rock doesn’t bother them.
Frontier Festivities
There’s also this interesting thread of “frontier Christmas” running through the list. Medora, Deadwood, Virginia City. You wouldn’t think old-West towns would vibe with candy-cane season, but they do.
Wooden sidewalks, old saloons, lanterns – it has its own charm, like a holiday postcard someone accidentally tea-stained.
River Sparkle
Water seems to matter more than people realize. River towns like Natchitoches, Paducah, and Fredericksburg were all included.
It’s not quite the coast and not quite mountains – but it’s atmospheric in its own way. A row of lights along a riverbank does a lot of heavy lifting.
Final Thoughts
When you take a broader view, the list doesn’t actually settle on one aesthetic. It’s mountains, coasts, Victorian streets, red rocks, and western boardwalks.
What ties them together is something softer: places that feel preserved, walkable, and a little slower than the rest of the world — exactly the kind of settings where Hallmark storylines tend to begin.
